English

What Were Watson'S Observations on the Stick Left Behind by Dr. Mortimer? How Far Did Sherlock Holmes Prove Him Wrong? - English Core

Advertisements
Advertisements

Question

What were Watson's observations on the stick left behind by Dr. Mortimer? How far did Sherlock Holmes prove him wrong? (in about 125 words)

Solution

Watson likens the stick left behind by Dr. Mortimer to what ‘the old-fashioned family practitioner used to carry’. He observes the worn out condition of the stick and concludes that the man must be a ‘successful, elderly medical man’ who practises in the countryside and travels a lot on foot. The silver band also displays the words ‘from his friends of the C.C.H.’ and the year ‘1884’. Watson infers that the stick must have been a presentation from a local hunt.
 

Holmes, however, after examining the stick himself, declares most of his friend’s conclusion to be ‘erroneous’. He points out that the stick must have been presented to the doctor by a hospital and C.C.H. would then mean ‘Charing Cross Hospital’. He further reasons that Dr Mortimer must have practised in town before shifting his practice to the country five years back; that he is a young man under thirty; that he is ‘amiable’, ‘unambitious’ and ‘absent-minded’; and that he possesses a dog, whose teeth marks are visible on the stick.

shaalaa.com
Reading Skills
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
2013-2014 (March) All India Set 1

RELATED QUESTIONS

Answer the following in 120-150 words : 

Within a few days of his arrival in Iping, people became suspicious of Griffin. Why?


Certain words in the poem are in capital letters — why?


Now write what you observe in the following two pictures.


Choose the odd one out :

Bottom, Moth, Mustardseed, Cobweb.


What are the games/play activities, entertainments that use a wheel?


Write a conversation between a donkey and a horse.


Form groups of 4-5. Read the following sentences aloud. Using your imagination and with the help of group discussion, write other situations in which the sentences can be used.

  • The outcome: disappointment and anger. 
  • The hour of battle had sounded
  • What a chase!
  • This was our chance, .........

Read ‘The Story of the Amulet’ by E. Nesbit.


Form groups of 5-8. This passage tells us only what the compère says. Try to visualize and write what the other people on the dais must have said in their speeches (Write only the main points.)

  • The School Principal
  • The Chief Guest
  • The Art teacher who offered a vote of thanks

Which lines are repeated in the poem? What do they mean?


Who said the following, to whom, and when?

“O Holy Master, bless us with thy song !”


Read the word. Write the words that combine to make it.

stepmother 


Describe the following with the help of the (The Twelve Months) story.

Summer


Describe the following with the help of the (The Twelve Months) story.

Winter 


Read the highlighted words. They are adverbs.

  • I was pulling hard.
  • They ran away.
  • Later, I was taken to the city.
  • I went very carefully.
  • They were greatly pleased.

What examples of plentiful things does the poet give?


Why did he spill the milk?


Who is wise according to you?


What do you infer about speaking with others from this poem?


Grandfather helped grandma out with the gardening because he______.


What does the tamarind give?


Gulliver was the captain of the ship.


A day in Mars is called ______.


Our planet is called the _____.


The boy was rather unsympathetic to his sister.


Mr. Murugan is a farmer. He has a small piece of land and two bulls. He takes good care of his bulls as they help him in farming. Every morning, he takes the bulls for grazing. When it rains he ploughs the land with the bulls. As he has no one to help he starts sowing the seed before sunrise. He irrigates the crop till it grows. He reaps and binds the crop then takes it to thrash the paddy. Finally, with the help of the bulls, he takes the paddy to his house.

Name the actions of Murugan.

 
 
 

Karmugilan went to __________ for higher studies.


Circle and write the adverbs.

Suddenly the old man fainted. ______


Pick out the rhyming words and write.

green  
human  
will  
welfare  

The Delhi government did not allow blind children to study Science after ____________.


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×