Advertisements
Advertisements
Question
Quite often a film made out of a book is not very successful. Discuss.
Solution
There is a wide range of differences between films and literary work. Every literary work has an irrational aspect that forms the basis of its existence. This irrational dimension is the inherent seed of every literary work and makes a reader connect to it.
The bitter part is that most of the time this aspect of literary creation is not physical. It is an emotion that can be struck through innumerable written lines but can never be put into enactment and converted into films.
Even after knowing this, when a literary work is forcefully converted into a movie, the nucleus or the purpose of the movie is in the mist. Or the adjustments done to put the novel in terms of a film breaks the backbone of the movie and takes the magic element away from it.
APPEARS IN
RELATED QUESTIONS
What childhood memories does the author recollect that had a bearing on his later involvement with filmmaking?
What connection does the author draw between filmmaking and conjuring?
What is the nature of the first impressions that form the basis for a film?
Which art form is film-making closest to? What is the reason for the similarity?
What, according to Bergman, is the relationship between a filmmaker and his audience?
What is the story of the Cathedral of Chartres and how does the author relate it to his profession?
What are some of the flaws of the world of filmmaking today?
Pick out examples from the text that show Bergman’s sensitivity to sensory impressions which have made him a great filmmaker.
What do you understand of the complexity of the little invisible steps that go into the making of a good film?
What are some of the risks that film-making involves?
What misgivings does Bergman have about the contemporary film industry?
Compare Bergman’s views about making films out of books with that of Umberto Eco’s.
According to the author, split-second impressions form a ‘mental state, not an actual story, but one abounding in fertile associations and images’.
Compare this with Virginia Woolf’s experiment with the stream of consciousness technique in ‘The Mark on the Wall’.
Bergman talks about the various influences in his life including his parents and his religious upbringing. To what extent are an individual’s achievements dependent on the kind of influences he or she has had in life? Discuss.
Autobiographical accounts make interesting reading when the author selects episodes that are connected to the pursuit of excellence. How does this apply to Ingmar Bergman’s narration of the details of film-making?
Comment on the conversational tone of the narration. Compare this with the very informal style adopted by Umberto Eco in the interview.
Think of a particular episode that could be enacted. Now imagine that you are a scriptwriter and write the screenplay for the first ten minutes of the episode, in the following format
| Title : | |
| Actors : | |
| Scene - 1 | |
| Description | Dialogue |
The column ‘Dialogue’ would contain the words to be actually spoken by the characters. ‘Description’ would include instructions regarding stage props, the position of lights, movement of actors, and so on.
What apprehensions does Ingram harbour regarding the contemporary film industry?
