English

What Are the Demerits of Mendeleev’S Periodic Table? - Science and Technology 1

Advertisements
Advertisements

Questions

What are the demerits of Mendeleev’s periodic table?

Write the demerits of Mendeleev's periodic table.

Long Answer

Solution

Demerits of Mendeleev’s periodic table:

1. The whole number atomic mass of the elements cobalt (Co) and nickel (Ni) is the same. Therefore there was ambiguity regarding their sequence in Mendeleev’s periodic table.

2. Isotopes were discovered a long time after Mendeleev put forth the periodic table. As isotopes have the same chemical properties but different atomic masses, a challenge was posed in placing them in Mendeleev’s periodic table.

3. When elements are arranged in increasing order of atomic masses, the rise in atomic mass does not appear to be uniform. It was not possible, therefore, to predict how many elements could be discovered between two heavy elements.

4. Position of hydrogen: Hydrogen shows similarity with halogens (group VII). For example, the molecular formula of hydrogen is H2 while the molecular formulae of fluorine and chlorine are F2 and Cl2, respectively. In the same way, there is a similarity in the chemical properties of hydrogen and alkali metals (group I). There is a similarity in the molecular formulae of the compounds of hydrogen alkali metals (Na, K, etc.) formed with chlorine and oxygen. On considering the above properties it can not be decided whether the correct position of hydrogen is in the group of alkali metals (group I) or in the group of halogens (group VII).

shaalaa.com
  Is there an error in this question or solution?
Chapter 2: Periodic Classication of Element - Answer the Following

RELATED QUESTIONS

 Name two elements that have two electrons in their outermost shells.


Name three elements with filled outermost shells.


Lithium, sodium, potassium are all metals that react with water to liberate hydrogen gas. Is there any similarity in the atoms of these elements?


Helium is an unreactive gas and neon is a gas of extremely low reactivity. What, if anything, do their atoms have in common?


By considering their position in the Periodic Table, which one of the following elements would you expect to have maximum metallic characteristic?


Element X forms a chloride with the formula XCl2, which is a solid with a high melting point. X would most likely be in the same group of the Periodic Table as


State any three demerits of Mendeleev’s periodic table.


On what basis elements are arranged in periodi table now?


State whether the following statement is true of false:

According to Mendeleev's periodic law, the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic numbers.


State Mendeleev's periodic law.


Why did Mendel choose garden pea for his experiments? Write two reasons.


Write a short note.
Mendeleev’s periodic law.


State Mendeleev's periodic law.


Why did Mendeleev's leave some gaps in his periodic table os elements? Explain your answer with an example.


How many elements were known at the time of Mendeleev's classification of elements?


Answer the following question:

Name two elements having a single electron in their outermost shell. 


What were the defects and anomalies in Mendeleeff's Periodic Table and how are they resolved by Moseley? 


Beryllium : alkaline earth metal : : sodium: _______


While designing the periodic table, Mendeleev considered the chemical and physical properties of the elements.


Write scientific reason.

Mendeleev kept vacant places in the periodic table.


Write scientific reason.

There was no definitive place for isotope in Mendeleev’s periodic table.


Distinguish between:

Mendeleev’s periodic table - Modern periodic table


On which basis Mendeleev organised periodic law?


What physical and chemical properties of elements did Mendeleev consider in compiling the periodic table?


What challenges did Mendeleev face in following periodic law?


In Mendeleev’s Periodic Table, gaps were left for the elements to be discovered later. Which of the following elements found a place in the Periodic Table later?


The total number of electrons present in the first twenty elements of the periodic table is ______ 


According to Mendeléev's Periodic Law, the elements were arranged in the periodic table in the order of


Which of the following statement (s) about the Modern Periodic Table are incorrect

  1. The elements in the Modern Periodic Table are arranged on the basis of their decreasing atomic number
  2. The elements in the Modern Periodic Table are arranged on the basis of their increasing atomic masses
  3. Isotopes are placed in adjoining group (s) in the Periodic Table
  4. The elements in the Modern Periodic Table are arranged on the basis of their increasing atomic number

In Mendeléev’s Periodic Table the elements were arranged in the increasing order of their atomic masses. However, cobalt with atomic mass of 58.93 amu was placed before nickel having an atomic mass of 58.71 amu. Give reason for the same.


Which group of elements could be placed in Mendeléev's Periodic Table without disturbing the original order? Give reason.


Give an account of the process adopted by Mendeléev for the classification of elements. How did he arrive at “Periodic Law”?


List the features of Mendeleev’s Periodic Table.


Mendeleev's periodic table was based on ______.


Share
Notifications

Englishहिंदीमराठी


      Forgot password?
Use app×